New! Covergirl Ink It! Eyeliner (In Charcoal Ink)

Hello night owls! Welcome back, tonights review is all about the new covergirl Ink It! Eyeliner crayon. As titled above, I purchased this in the color charcoal ink. I meant to buy the black one and accidently bought this one. Since I have blue/grey eyes I decided to keep it and ended up being content with the look of it on my top and bottom lash line. This eyeliner was $6.97 (I think) at walmart. I usually use the Revlon Colorstay Eyeliner in Black Brown, but I just finished it up and decided to try this instead because Casey Holmes on Youtube had a good word on it. The eyeliner itself is from the 'Perfect Points Plus' eyeliner collection and has a self sharpening tip that twists up when needed. I was skeptical when using it because most 'Charcoal' or grey colored eyeliners are quite light and ashy. This one surprised me though as it is very close to black which was what I was going for. It claims to be smudge proof & waterproof, however it is not waterproof as Casey Holmes stated, but is it smudgeproof which is what I have to have because my eyeliner always smudges and creases on my top lid. (Ugh so embarassing & annoying). This eyeliner lasts about 12 hrs which is pretty good considering how hot its been out. (Chicago Area) Overall I would have to rate this to be a 7.5 out of 10 just because Im not quite sure whether it beats my go to eyeliner from Revlon Colorstay. I would still recommend this is you have experienced smudging and creasing from eyeliner as this stays put and lasts a good amount of time. Stay tuned for a long overdue  June Favorites blog post and future 'Products I've Emptied/Used up' Blog Post coming soon. Until then goodnight my beauties! Xoxoxo, Karlie